| This
article was excerpted from the address
presented by 2003 ASA President James
E. Cottrell, M.D., to the ASA House of
Delegates on October 12, 2003, in San
Francisco, California. |
|
When Barry Glazer gave me the President’s
medallion last year, I was excited about the prospect
of accomplishing our goals, which included:
• Support research and encourage more
appreciation of our science among clinicians
• Build better ties between the ASA, academic
anesthesiology and anesthesiologists in private
practice
• Build better bridges with other specialty
physician organizations and with international
groups, and
• Increase our efforts to educate Americans
and their legislators about what we do to safeguard
their lives.
Part of appreciating where we are and where we
might be headed comes from knowing how we got here
— and who sent us. Names like Erdmann, Rovenstine,
Apgar, Waters, Lundy and Bonica come to mind. I
want to begin my remarks today by praising three
anesthesiologists and one lawyer who joined our
noble ancestry since we met last year in Orlando,
Florida.
Frank McKechnie, M.D., pioneered recovery room care
in the 1950s. Today we take this critical link between
the O.R. and the hospital floor for granted, but
I hate to think how high anesthesia-related mortality
would have been in the 1960s and 1970s had it not
been for Frank McKechnie.
Peter Safar, M.D., the “Father” of CPR,
did for critical care and emergency medical transport
what McKechnie did for the recovery room. As put
by the Pittsburgh Post, “ …Peter
Safar’s life was dedicated to cheating death.”
He was nominated for the Nobel Prize three times.
Those people in Stockholm missed their chance. My
guess is that some of them would not have had the
chance to miss their chance, were it not for the
contributions of Peter Safar.
In addition to Safar and McKechnie, we have the
legacy of Manny Papper, M.D., to build upon. By
being first in the right place at the right time,
he trained more anesthesiology chairs than any other
mentor to date. The publisher of the Miami Herald
captured Manny Papper best when he wrote, “No
one who experienced his gentlemanly manner would
have guessed at the force of his will.”
The lawyer I mentioned is Jack Lansdale. To us he
is known as the ASA’s wise counsel for almost
30 years, but to history he is known as the Lieutenant
Colonel who led American forces to Germany’s
atomic bomb project before the Red Army could reach
it, capturing Werner Heisenberg and Otto Hahn, among
others, at the end of World War II.
How should we spend this inheritance … the
legacy of our heroes? Papper, McKechnie and Safar
would advise us to invest in our most fundamental
asset — the SCIENCE of anesthesiology. The
drugs and the tools and the knowledge that enable
us to make a living …come from research …
and just doing everything that we already know how
to do is not an option. We need to do all of those
things better, and we need to learn to do things
that have never been done before.
So how do we, the ASA, encourage and support research
in anesthesiology? This meeting is a great example
with “Research Taking Center Stage at Our
Annual Meeting.” Tomorrow Terri G. Monk, M.D.,
will present the Emery A. Rovenstine Memorial Lecture
on “Postoperative Cognitive Dysfunction: The
Next Challenge in Geriatric Anesthesia,” (if
not anesthesia in general!). After her lecture,
our highest award for research, the Award for Excellence
in Research will be presented to Mervyn Maze, M.B.,
Ch.B. Our Distinguished Service Award will be presented
to Bernard V. Wetchler, M.D., a pioneer in establishing
ambulatory surgery. Then, in its first appearance,
I will have the pleasure of initiating the Annual
Presidential Scholar Award to Peter J. Pronovost,
M.D., for his groundbreaking work on the systematization
of patient safety. Dr. Pronovost has devised and
tested measures of performance in the ICU. For the
sake of our patients, our organization and our profession,
we need to promote Dr. Pronovost’s ideas.
The connection between what we do as an organization
and the implementation of such breakthroughs is
direct and solid and very important.
Equally solid and important is the financial underpinning
that pays for our support — the funding that
we get from government, the grants that we get from
industry and, ultimately, the money that we get
paid to do our jobs (which I’m sure most of
you are less interested in [laughter from audience]).
Let me bore you with just one example of how ASA
pursues such matters.
Documents and arguments and correspondence play
their part, but if you really want to get something
done, for instance about Medicare reimbursement,
you have to talk to Tom Scully, Administrator of
the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services.
That’s easier said than done, because several
thousand people from several hundred organizations
want to bend Mr. Scully’s ear about Medicare
reimbursement, and as far as most of them know,
the line forms at the end, and most appointments
run about 10 minutes.
There is, however, an alternate path. If you know
a prominent U.S. Senator who can get Tom Scully’s
attention, and if you can get that person to write
or call Mr. Scully, you can then round-up Roberta
Hines, M.D., Michael Scott, J.D., Karin Bierstein,
J.D., and Alexander A. Hannenberg, M.D., for a nice
long sit-down with Mr. Scully. We did just that
for a very engaging hour and five minutes last July
22. On our way out, Mike Scott turned to me in amazement
and exclaimed, “You’re the luckiest
man in the world!”
Mike was right. I have been lucky enough to become
the President of ASA, and I have been lucky enough
to have the help of ASA professionals like Ronald
A. Bruns, Denise M. Jones, Jill A. Formeister, Janice
L. Plack, Susan M. Rogowski, Philip S. Weintraub,
Manuel Bonilla, S. Diane Turpin, J.D., Karin Bierstein,
J.D., Sharon Merrick, Lisa Percy, and yes, Mike
Scott, our own Director of Governmental and Legal
Affairs — a genius, in my opinion, who has
worked with us for the past 28 years of his life
helping advance our specialty’s interests.
Mike is retiring at the end of next year. How lucky
was I to get one of his last full years of service?
[looking over at Dr. Litwiller] And Roger, how lucky
are you to get his last full year and his 30th?
Please let me draw your attention to one more ASA
stalwart — our portrait photographer, Chad
Evans Wyatt — whether capturing a renowned
Czech artist, a famous newscaster or an ASA President,
Chad Wyatt makes our images shine. Thank you, Chad,
for making ASA Officers look good for the past 14
years.
Let me close with a message about our collective
image — the image of anesthesiologists. The
October 2003 ASA NEWSLETTER has an article
by Robert E. Johnstone, M.D., about the many anesthesiologists
serving in Iraq and Afghanistan and about colleagues
like Scott M. Croll, M.D., who administered anesthesia
to frontline troops and Iraqi civilians during the
siege of Baghdad.
Fortunately, Dr. Croll is with us today, as is Col.
John Chiles, 25th Chief of Army Anesthesiology.
Dr. Croll, Dr. Chiles, Dr. Johnstone, please stand,
and let us express our gratitude for what you have
done for our troops, for the people of Iraq and
for the image of our specialty [standing ovation].
In contrast to Dr. Johnstone’s article, a
long article in The New York Times, which
has a somewhat larger circulation than the ASA
NEWSLETTER [laughs from audience], shows pictures
of anesthesiologists in action in Iraq but only
surgeons are interviewed. The article discusses
the things that we do, right down to airway management,
but the words “anesthesiology” and “anesthesiologist”
are never mentioned.
It’s not that we have a negative public image,
but we do have an inadequate image. Too many people,
including too many people who should know better,
think that we just put patients to sleep. I got
that message loud and clear one day when I was waiting
outside my office while medical students gathered
inside for an introduction to our field. I overheard
one student ask, “What do anesthesiologists
do?” The answer came back, “They put
people to sleep.”
I walked in, introduced myself and asked them to
imagine the following: “You’re lying
face up on a cold steel table, covered only by a
sheet. People in disposable gowns appear at your
side. One of them pulls off your sheet and cuts
the skin over your sternum with a razor blade —
right down to the bone. Then he saws through your
chest, inserts a crank and winds you open until
he can grab your heart. After hooking you up to
a pump, he cuts a valve out of your heart and sews
in a valve from a pig, then he puts your parts back
in place and staples you back together.
How many of you could sleep through that?”
They got the message.
We need to get the truth out in the open. We need
to shine by telling people who we are and what we
do. Anesthesiologists are doctors who make surgery
possible. We keep patients alive while surgeons
do things that would otherwise kill them. Everybody
needs to know that, and we need to tell them.
So we have a lot on our plate — clinical care,
research, teaching, professional society organization,
government lobbying and even public relations. As
Gertrude Stein once said, long before the Internet
and even before television, “Everybody gets
so much information all day long that they lose
their common sense.” We all know that feeling,
but we all need to do as much as we can and still
do everything well, because, like Alice in Wonderland,
you have to run as fast as you can just to stay
in the same place!
Thank you for letting me run, and thank you for
letting me serve as the President of this wonderful
organization.
| |
|
James E. Cottrell, M.D., is Professor and Chair,
Department of Anesthesiology, and Senior Associate
Dean for Clinical Practice, State University
of New York Health Sciences Center at Brooklyn,
New York. |
|
|