Mentoring Research: Reclaiming Our Role as Research
Leaders John
P. Kampine, M.D., Ph.D., Chair
Academy of Anesthesiology Mentors
Foundation for Anesthesia Education and Research
Myer H. Rosenthal, M.D., Immediate Past Chair
Board of Directors
Foundation for Anesthesia Education and Research
he
Foundation for Anesthesia Education and Research
(FAER), joined by an increasing number of anesthesiology
department chairs and others in academic anesthesiology,
has been extremely concerned over the insufficient
level of anesthesia research originated from our
anesthesia programs. It has become quite evident
that anesthesiology’s share of national competitive
funding as measured by data from the National Institutes
of Health (NIH) as a specialty is far below that
which should be expected. Examination of NIH funding
over the past several years to 2003 demonstrates
a growth in its research budget of more than 16
percent annually as anesthesiology’s share
increased less than 1 percent, receiving only 0.3
percent of available NIH research funds. With the
annual budget of NIH, beginning with 2004, increasing
at a far lower rate of 2.5 percent and with 2005
at 1.99 percent and 2006 at 0.88 percent, the anesthesiology
community is in jeopardy of even further erosion
of research support. One of the critical indicators
of the vital role of academic anesthesia as a major
component of anesthesiology as a medical specialty
is the continued quest for new knowledge that expands
our ability to provide the best care for our patients.
Further evidence of the critical state of anesthesia
research and research training is found in examining
the numbers of academic anesthesiology training
programs receiving NIH funding. Of the 128 programs
approved by the Accreditation Council for Graduate
Medical Education, only 54 received any funding
in 2004, with 19 of those receiving only one or
two grants. Furthermore, of the 1,322 NIH training
grants awarded in 2004, only 10 were received by
anesthesiology departments.
Recognizing the need for improved academic research
productivity, FAER organized an internal advisory
committee in 2002 to provide information on mentoring
and how FAER could promote and enhance the activities
of mentors with regard to the academic career development
of anesthesiologists in research and education.
The committee consisted of Alex S. Evers, M.D.,
Simon Gelman, M.D., Ph.D., John P. Kampine, M.D.,
Ronald D. Miller, M.D., and Ronald G. Pearl, M.D.,
Ph.D., and was chaired by Dr. Kampine. During the
course of several meetings, the committee recommended
to the FAER Board of Directors that career development
awards (FAER Research Training Grants) given to
mentored awardees be accompanied by a stipend awarded
to the recipient’s mentor through the mentor’s
department with the stipulation that the mentor
be provided identifiable time for mentoring the
FAER awardee. This recommendation was approved and
is now incorporated into the FAER Research Training
Grant.
The committee also recommended that an organization
be established consisting of mentors whose contribution
to the academic development of anesthesiology trainees
is recognized to be at the highest level. The Academy
of Anesthesia Mentors was established in 2004. The
objective of the Academy is to recognize those individuals
who, through their activities as mentors, have made
important contributions to the development and advancement
of academic anesthesiologists in the areas of research
and education. An additional objective is to promote
the activities of mentoring among others in the
specialty of anesthesiology with the goal of increasing
academic activities in research and education and
promoting the academic image of anesthesiology.
At the present time, membership includes 30 individuals
representing 19 academic departments. At its next
meeting, topics to be covered will include membership,
bylaws, organizational activities and short-term
versus long-term goals.
Although much additional effort must be made to
improve the current levels of academic productivity
in our specialty, it is hoped that the initial steps
identified above will begin to provide the impetus
and enthusiasm for the progress that is so vital
to the future growth of our medical specialty.
| |
|
John
P. Kampine, M.D., Ph.D., is Professor of Anesthesiology
and Physiology, Medical College of Wisconsin,
Milwaukee, Wisconsin. |
|
| |
|
Myer H. Rosenthal, M.D., is Professor of Anesthesiology,
Medicine and Surgery, Stanford University School
of Medicine, Stanford, California. |
|
|