Editor’s Note:
Due to a change in American Board
of Anesthesiology policy, residents-in-training
and graduates are no longer reported
by country of medical school graduation.
The editor is personally grateful to
Dr. Grogono for his efforts in reporting
the changes in anesthesiology residency.
— D.R.B.
|
|
he major change this year is a significant increase
in the number of residents in the CA-1 year. Other
changes are less remarkable and show no unanticipated
changes from last year. Accordingly, fewer tables
and graphs accompany this year’s report.
Data Reporting: As in last year’s
article, a resident’s postgraduate year (PGY)
status is based on the number of months of training
credited by the American Board of Anesthesiology
(ABA). The more familiar terminology, however, is
employed so that, for example, clinical anesthesiology
year one (CA-1) is used instead of PGY-2.
Anesthesiology Residents in Training [Table
1]: This year the number of residents in
the critical CA-1 year increased by 9.2 percent,
from 1,439 to 1,572 making it the largest CA-1 group
since 1994. The total remains smaller, however,
than the peak of 1,904 recorded in 1992.
| Table 1 |
 |
| The numbers graduating and in each year
of anesthesiology residencies, 1985-05. |
| Figure 1 |
 |
| Graph showing the total number of medical
graduates in anesthesiology residencies, 1960-05. |
The size of the PGY-1 year (514), although of lesser
significance than the CA-1 year, represents a comparable
increase. This increase, however, merely returned
the size of the PGY-1 year to the 2003 level, and
also to the average for the last 10 years.
Anesthesiology Residents Graduating and
Resident Annual Totals [Tables 1 and 2 and Figure
1]: Almost exactly the same number graduated
this year (1,390) as did last year (1,393). This
is close to the average for the last 17 years (1,402)
but below the peak of 1,814 graduating in 1995.
The number of residents potentially available to
graduate in the next three years, without attrition,
are 1,513, 1,557 and 1,572.
Attrition From Residencies [Table 1 and Figure 2]:
The size of the CA-1 group in a given year, e.g.,
2002, is compared to the value for the same cohort
in 2005, i.e., the graduating group. In addition
to attrition, however, the actual composition of
this group also is affected by other factors, e.g.,
ill health, childbirth, relocation and being held
back for additional training. For these reasons,
the actual numerical values must be interpreted
with caution. The data are presented here to show
trends and comparisons between years.
| Table 2 |
 |
| The number of medical graduates in anesthesiology
residency programs, 1960-05. |
| Figure 2 |
 |
| Attrition from residencies.
Each year plots the number starting in the CA-1
cohort for that year (CA-1) and the size of
the same cohort three years later (Grad). |
For a given year, e.g., 1995, one point shows the
size of the CA-1 group for that year and another,
just below it, shows the size of that cohort graduating,
e.g., in 1998. In the early years, the number graduating
three years later was close to the number in the
CA-1 group. In the mid 1990s, the graphs diverged
as fewer residents graduated than had started the
training. This change occurred during a period of
anxiety about employment opportunities; residents
were leaving anesthesiology, and the attrition was
largely voluntary. This loss was followed by a decline
in the number of applicants, and this in turn was
followed by a period of vigorous recruitment. The
loss of residents continued, however, and appears
to have been caused by compulsory attrition. Today
the rate of attrition has declined but not yet to
the levels of the late 1980s cohorts.
Gender [Table 3]: ABA has now collected
data about the gender distribution in anesthesiology
residencies for five consecutive years. For the
first four years, the percentage of women being
trained hovered around 27 percent with no evident
trend. This year, however, the percentage of women
in the PGY-1 year has risen to 33 percent and in
the CA-1 year to 32 percent.
| Table 3 |
 |
| The percentage of women in anesthesiology
residency programs by year, 2000-05. |
Discussion: This year the number
of residency positions filled via the National Resident
Matching Program rose to 1,230, the largest number
ever recorded. This occurred despite a reduction
in the number of places offered via the Match. This
growth via the Match in March has now been followed
by an additional growth in the size of the CA-1
year. For the five years, 2000 to 2004, the size
of the CA-1 group changed relatively slightly and
averaged 1,465. This year there were 1,572 residents
in the CA-1 year, a jump of 133 and 107 (7.3 percent)
above the average. The number of women entering
the specialty (32 percent of the CA-1 year) appears
to be rising, although it is still below the percentage
of women entering medicine.
Attrition during the residency has changed little
from last year and remains around 5 percent for
the duration of the residency. This is only slightly
above the low levels enjoyed 15 years ago.
Conclusion: The increase in the
size of the CA-1 year is in contrast to recent years
and would appear to be significant. It will be several
years, however, before this increase can appreciably
affect the size of the workforce. With a growing
population and the continuing shortage of anesthesiologists,
this is a welcome trend, as is the increase in the
number of women selecting anesthesiology.
Nurse Anesthetist Data: From 2001
to 2004, this report included data about the number
of nurse anesthetists graduating, being certified
and working. This year the data have not been made
available because they are derived from survey data,
and the data are regarded as proprietary by the
American Association of Nurse Anesthetists.
Acknowledgment: As usual it is
a pleasure to thank Francis P. Hughes, Ph.D., of
the American Board of Anesthesiology. His efficient
help makes it possible to produce this report promptly.
Web Site: To see previous articles,
additional data about the workforce and the results
of the National Resident Matching Program, readers
are invited to visit <www.grogono.com/nrmp>.
| |
|
Alan
W. Grogono, M.D., now retired, is former Chair
and Meryl and Sam Israel Professor, Department
of Anesthesiology, Tulane University School
of Medicine, New Orleans, Louisiana. |
|
|