isasters
are natural or manmade events where the casualty
numbers overwhelm the available medical and organizational
resources. Media coverage has brought these events
to public attention on a regular basis. Terrorist
attacks in urban areas involving explosive devices
and toxic agent release have emphasized that disaster
outside warfare can be deliberately produced. The
management of both physical and toxic trauma is
an expert domain where anesthesiologists have invaluable
skills in both prehospital and hospital management.
In many parts of the world, anesthesiologists are
leaders of prehospital emergency and disaster care.1
They assume leadership roles of international organizations
such as the World Association for Disaster and Emergency
Medicine and the International Trauma Anesthesia
and Critical Care Society.2,
3
Worldwide Leaders in Preparedness and Response
Anesthesiologists around the world have been in
the forefront of disaster preparedness and response.
In France, anesthesiologists lead the prehospital
emergency care with the Service d’Aide Médicale
Urgente and have an integral role in the operation
of prehospital disaster plans.4
Anesthesiologists worked in the Helicopter Emergency
Medical Service rapid-response units during the
July 2005 London subway bombings and were among
the first to deal with casualties, particularly
those requiring field amputation.5
In addition, in London, anesthesiologists work inside
the Chemical Hazards and Poisons Division and are
closely involved with the management of casualties
following a toxic agent release.6
It is not difficult to see why anesthesiologists
fit well into these roles. We are trained to manage
a broad spectrum of patients, from pediatrics to
geriatrics, from the healthy patient to the medically
complex patient and from the difficult elective
case to the hemodynamically unstable emergency case.
The special training of anesthesiologists provides
an in-depth understanding of pharmacology and applied
physiology together with essential life-support
skills, including line placement, volume resuscitation
and airway management. In daily practice, we ventilate
most of our patients and thus we are adept at handling
challenging respiratory and ventilation cases. No
other specialty has such depth and breadth of education
and daily practice in hemodynamic monitoring, volume
resuscitation, medical management and airway management
of a diverse patient population.
From a historical perspective, it is clear that
anesthesiologists have tremendous experience and
skill to share with our colleagues in the management
of trauma and disaster situations both here in the
United States and globally. Anesthesiologists utilize
triage skills in the day-to-day management of the
flow of patients in our operating rooms (O.R.s),
postanesthesia care units and intensive care units.
Anesthesiologists must be adept at multitasking
in the aftermath of an attack with weapons of mass
destruction (WMD), offering care for several patients
simultaneously, often under adverse and austere
conditions. Nevertheless, with advance planning
and training, treatment can be delivered while minimizing
the harm of WMD — both to patients and responders.
Reliable and accurate information is necessary for
rational health policy. The recent weaponization
of biological agents such as anthrax has turned
what was once an unimaginable event into an actual
public health threat. In a WMD attack, medical personnel
will be in short supply. The ability of anesthesiologists
to participate effectively in emergency medical
care outside the O.R. is enhanced by the acquisition
of competency in advanced trauma life support (ATLS)
and basic principles of mass casualty and disaster
management. Coincident with shortages of health
care workers, there will be a limited need for O.R.
care and increased need for respiratory therapy
and intensive care. General anesthesiologists can
fulfill a variety of roles outside the O.R. In cases
of WMD attack, we can function as team members in
field medical teams, in the emergency room or in
the management of intensive care patients.
Obstacles to Overcome
Despite the obvious role for the anesthesiologist
in disaster care, there are many difficulties in
setting up models for practice. The first challenge
is to define clearly for both our medical colleagues
and the public alike the extended role of the anesthesiologist
beyond the daily work as a perioperative life support
physician. The second challenge is finding time
to plan and work outside of our traditional work
areas. The third challenge is the lack of regularly
scheduled administrative and out-of-O.R. clinical
time for training and field experience, particularly
overseas training experiences.
There also are concerns over the provision of malpractice
insurance coverage in the event of a disaster requiring
deployment. Should we allow economic and legal concerns
to keep us from proactive involvement in our hospitals
and community disaster preparedness and response?
If we do, are we neglecting the obvious important
contribution to patient care in the arenas of trauma,
chemical, biological and nuclear disaster management?
These concerns have led to a lack of integration
of many anesthesiologists’ perspective into
trauma and disaster preparedness programs. We lack
the understanding of our hospital administrations
as to the significant contribution we anesthesiologists
can and should make to this endeavor.
Anesthesiology was the first medical specialty to
identify patient safety as a specific focus. In
1984, ASA established the Anesthesia Patient Safety
Foundation (APSF).7 This approach has relevance
for the wider implications of prehospital and disaster
care. We should utilize the bridges previously built
among anesthesiologists, nurse anesthetists, manufacturers
of equipment, pharmaceutical companies, government
regulators, risk management attorneys and engineers
and build new bridges to our colleagues in the American
College of Emergency Physicians, the American College
of Surgeons and the American Medical Association.
Development of liaisons between ASA, APSF, the Federal
Emergency Management Agency and the Department of
Homeland Security will provide a way forward for
establishing an essential role of the anesthesiologist
in disaster management. Natural and manmade disasters
are a reality, and our profession must adapt and
develop to meet the necessary challenge.
What Can You Do Immediately?
Start at home with preparedness <www.ready.gov/america/index.html>.
In a safe place in your home, have a disaster kit
equipped for both the most common events in our
area and for the predicted influenza pandemic. Every
family member should know where it is. Make sure
your family knows how to contact you, as well as
each other, in the event of a disaster. This communication
should include a family member outside the state.
We cannot function as anesthesiologists if we are
worried about our own families.
Become certified in ATLS, national disaster life
support, Hospital Emergency Incident Command Structure
and personal protective equipment. These courses
are all available within the Brigham and Women’s
Hospital.
Get involved: Volunteer locally, at the state level
or regionally.
Develop a “disaster kit” for the main
O.R.s.
Be proactive! This is the only proven way to avert
an inadequate response to any disaster, whether
natural or manmade.
Please note that further articles on disaster preparedness
and volunteerism will appear in future NEWSLETTERS.
References:
1. Grande CM, Baskett PJ, Donchin Y, et al. Trauma
anesthesia for disaster: Anything, anytime, anywhere.
Crit Care Clin. 1991; 7:339-361.
2. Baskett P, Fisher J. T. Michael Moles: A life
to be celebrated. Prehosp Disast Med. 2001;
16(2):73-74.
3. Trauma Care International. The International
Trauma Anesthesia and Critical Care Society Home
Page. Available at <www.itaccs.com>.
4. Carli PA, Riou B, Barriot P. Trauma anesthesia
practices throughout the world: France. In: Grande
CM, ed. Textbook of Trauma Anesthesia and Critical
Care. St. Louis: Mosby Year Book Inc; 1993:199-204.
5. Lockey DJ, MacKenzie R, Redhead J, et al. London
bombings July 2005: The immediate pre-hospital response.
Resuscitation. 2005; 66: ix-xii.
6. Baker DJ, Personal communication, February 2006.
7. Anesthesia Patient Safety Foundation. APSF History
Overview. Available at <www.apsf.org/about/brief_history.mspx>.
Accessed on July 14, 2006.
| |
|
Jill
A. Antoine, M.D., is Associate Clinical Professor
of Anesthesiology, University of California-San
Francisco, San Francisco, California. |
|
|