hilanthropy
and involvement in nonprofit organizations can rekindle
a sense of purpose and satisfaction in a physician’s
professional life. Following is a description of
my travels through a philanthropic journey.
In the Beginning
The “private world” in which I have
practiced for nearly 20 years has offered a remarkable
and rich diversity of professional avenues to explore.
The autonomy to establish the unique mission of
the practice, the very personal relationships established
with long-term patients and the cultivation of capable
staff are deeply satisfying.
Unfortunately, the grind of private practice can
easily separate us from the sense of public service
and work for the greater good that is the hallmark
of the institutions in which most of us trained.
Philanthropy and public service, however, can be
found in abundance in the world of private practice.
In 1994, acting on the interest to add a public
service dimension to my practice, I asked my accountant
if it would be possible to set up a nonprofit corporation.
My hope was to establish a vehicle that could collect
funds from community members, patients and industry
partners and distribute them for the greater good
of our community and to less fortunate patients.
With a relatively small investment (but many forms
from the Internal Revenue Service), we successfully
received approval for a 501(c)(3) not-for-profit
organization called Napa Pain Resources. 501(c)
is a provision of the United States Internal Revenue
Code (26 U.S.C. § 501(c)), listing
types of nonprofit organizations exempt from some
federal income taxes.
Activities of Napa Pain Resources
Our original mission was to support research, education
and patient care in pain management in our community.
Our foundation has accomplished this in a number
of simple ways.
First of all, we have tried to help with transportation.
We all recognize that many patients with chronic
illness (especially chronic pain) have severe financial
stress. Our nonprofit has addressed this by providing
cab fare and transportation funds for patients so
they can keep their appointments. This seems simple,
but in the business of prescribing controlled substances
for pain, failure to keep appointments might be
viewed as a “red flag” by prescribing
doctors. It is sad when patients are considered
noncompliant and dismissed from well-intentioned
practices because they simply could not afford to
get there.
We have also been able to provide medications, in
special situations, for patients with implanted
infusion pumps. Patients with chronic illness often
have lapses in insurance coverage due to lost jobs
or during the delay between private insurance and
obtaining Medicare coverage. Our ability to supplement
our patients in this way has undoubtedly prevented
the necessity of explants for some of our patients.
Even the co-pay for expensive medications is out
of the reach of some patients with financial hardship.
The Napa Pain Conference
I founded the Napa Pain Conference in the early
1990s to bring first-quality pain education to our
community. Shortly after inception, the conference
has been the principal educational effort of our
foundation.
The 14th Napa Pain Conference, held this year in
Yountville, Napa Valley, last October 5-7, has been
a great success in community building and fund raising
for our nonprofit. We have been fortunate to have
many of the icons and leaders of our field speak
and attend over the years, and we have a dedicated
following of clinicians.
The 2008 version of the Napa Pain Conference will
offer participants unique exposure to community
service. In addition to an excellent clinical program,
we will offer a day-long workshop on nonprofits
and community philanthropy for participants.
Several internationally known foundations have tentatively
committed to the event, held each year during the
first week of October.
Renaming the Organization — The Margaret Dunn
Grigsby Foundation
My mother, Margaret Grigsby, was my model for philanthropy.
Born before the Great Depression in a small Tennessee
community in Appalachia, she had no money and little
opportunity for education. However, as so many in
her generation, she found remarkable ways to manage
our family and contribute, even while suffering
from her own serious and chronic illness.
Of course she would have thought the term “philanthropy”
was for rich people. She would have described her
tireless help for the needy as just helping out
her friends in the community. She showed me that
community service does not take money as much as
the instinct to look beyond ourselves. When my mom
passed on in 2004, we renamed the organization the
Margaret Dunn Grigsby Foundation.
Our Newest Commitment — Palliative Care in
Malawi, Eastern Africa
We have by no means solved the problem of access
to adequate pain services in Napa, California. Nevertheless,
we are compelled by my recent experiences in Malawi,
in eastern Africa, to contribute something to the
immense suffering of these people from the AIDS
pandemic, which is still in full swing.
Malawi is a small, land-locked country of 12 million
people in southeast Africa. English is the official
language, as it was once a British protectorate.
There exists a long history of missionary work and
philanthropy aimed at health care and community
improvement. Despite these efforts, Malawi depends
nearly entirely on donations from Europe, the United
States and developed countries for its economy.
The society is traditional and agrarian, with more
than 90 percent of the population living without
electricity or running water.
Like many third-world countries, the public health
challenges in Malawi are immense. Dirty water, cholera
in the rainy season and malaria are endemic. The
health system is primarily funded by the government,
which operates on a very limited budget. Other than
the excellent work of church-sponsored hospitals,
no meaningful private sector exists.
HIV/AIDS has been devastating to the people of Malawi.
It is estimated that as many as 2 million of the
12 million total population are HIV-positive. Of
course with few testing centers and laboratories,
and with most patients living in the countryside
with no transportation, that estimate is probably
low. Incomprehensibly, more than 1 million children
in Malawi have been orphaned by AIDS.
Treatment for AIDS is very limited, with only 5
percent of those infected receiving anti-retroviral
medications (ARVs). Medical decisions in Malawi
are very functional and practical in the face of
limited medications. For example, HIV-positive patients
do not receive ARVs until they develop AIDS. Those
with AIDS, also sick with tuberculosis or cancer,
do not receive ARVs as they are deemed too sick
to benefit.
Palliative care in Malawi and throughout sub-Saharan
Africa is in its infancy. The use of very limited
resources of medications such as morphine to make
dying patients more comfortable has not been seen
as a practical.
Our nonprofit is working with the Health Ministry
in Lilongwe, the capital of Malawi, to begin a three-part
educational process for palliative care. Working
with the fledgling Palliative Care Association of
Malawi, or PACAM, we are helping to write a curriculum
in palliative care for the small medical school
and the school of nursing.
In cooperation with the Global AIDS Interfaith Alliance
(GAIA) in San Francisco, we are exploring a pilot
project in pain relief. GAIA has a relationship
with 37 villages in Malawi and provides orphan care,
AIDS support and community development. We are exploring
ways to get analgesics (morphine is the cheapest
and easiest to handle) to communities and to educate
communities in their use.
Of course the challenges in pain management in Malawi
parallel our experiences here in some ways. Clinicians
receive little or no education regarding pain management
or the concept of palliative care. Some even view
palliative care as a waste of resources on the hopelessly
sick. “Opiophobia” is alive and well,
as patients requesting morphine are still viewed
with suspicion. The problems of diversion are amplified
in an impoverished economy, as morphine has a tangible
street value in real currency.
Unlike in the United States, however, morphine is
simply physically unavailable. By my informal calculation,
the amount of morphine available in an entire year
in Malawi is used in a year by a single small community
hospital in the United States. Dosing is dissimilar
as well. In home visits for palliative care, I have
seen patients and families who describe dramatic
pain relief with 5 to 10 milligrams of morphine
in 24 hours orally.
The challenges are large and our abilities are small.
But each life changed for the better is important,
and so we are determined and inspired by the opportunities.
Future Opportunities
It is no news that physicians are under something
of a relentless assault in our country. Autonomy
in clinical decision-making, financial compensation
and our sense of place in society have eroded to
the point of discouragement. Anesthesiology, in
many ways, is on the ragged, leading edge of these
trends.
Recapturing some of the joy and satisfaction lost
from our careers may be difficult, but one place
to look is in the world of nonprofits. This realm
is populated by generous people with passion, spirit
and community purpose, which were alive in us all
in the early days. I encourage you to explore the
possibilities, as the needs are as great as your
vision to contribute.
| |
|
Eric
J. Grigsby, M.D., is Medical Director, Spectrum
Care Pain Treatment Center, Napa, California. |
|
|