very
year, the ASA Committee on Overseas Anesthesia Teaching
Program recruits anesthesiologists to volunteer
one or two months to go to Rwanda or Tanzania and
teach in one of their teaching hospitals. One of
the first questions interested candidates ask us
is, “What is it like to be a volunteer?”
Many of our volunteers are “repeaters,”
a few for three or more times. Perhaps the best
way to explain it is to include some comments from
the post-tour report of one of our volunteers to
Rwanda last September.
Notes From a Volunteer
I will preface this report by saying that Rwanda
was the most rewarding mission in which I have
been involved. What I had to teach was eagerly
received. Each and every member of the anesthesiology
department was pleasant and welcoming. I fully
intend to return to Rwanda annually.
Rwanda is an East African country with very few
resources and a tumultuous modern history. It
is thus no surprise that health care has suffered
as a result. Infectious pathology accounts for
about 85 percent of the diseases and consumes
the lion’s share of the health care funding.
This climate is thus less than conducive to the
practice of surgical specialties, including anesthesiology.
Rwanda has one medical school, which graduates
about 60 physicians annually. After graduation,
those physicians are required to work at district
hospitals for a period of time, after which one
of two pathways is open to them. They can apply
for a residency in one of the medical specialties
or apply for a job with one of the NGOs (non-governmental
organizations). The latter pathway is twice as
lucrative and requires no residency. This presents
a major obstacle to recruiting physicians to anesthesiology.
As a result, the bulk of the anesthesia workforce
is composed of nurse anesthetists.
There are a total of nine residents in the only
program in the country, NUR (National University
of Rwanda). I have worked almost daily with two
of them and found them to be very eager and intelligent.
They were surprisingly computer savvy and contributed
very useful information from anesthesiology-related
Web sites. Historically, residents have been sent
for a year abroad in Belgium or France. (Editorial
note: French is their first language, but teaching
is done in English.) The current thinking is to
do away with this rotation for fear of brain drain.
Didactic teaching is based on a set of modules.
I taught the respiratory physiology module, which
I expanded to include the anesthesia breathing
circuits and respiratory pathophysiology.
The chairperson of anesthesia is, to date, the
only Rwandan fully qualified anesthesiologist.
She did all of her training in Belgium. A number
of non-Rwandan physicians staff the operating
room. They come from Belgium, Burundi, Egypt,
Madagascar and Uganda. The modus operandi is that
all cases of the day are discussed at 7 a.m. at
the staff morning report, including attendings,
nurse anesthetists and the residents on the rotation.
Patients are presented, and anesthetic plans are
discussed. The nurse anesthetists carry out the
bulk of the work in the presence of the residents,
when available. The staff anesthesiologist, who
is immediately available, is called upon when
difficulty arises.
There are four O.R.s where elective procedures
are performed. Some are familiar to North American
volunteers — hernias, ENT work, fractures,
etc. Many patients have badly neglected pathology
rarely seen in the West: giant sarcomas and maxillofacial
tumors, Kaposi sarcomas, and so on. One of the
three O.R.s is dedicated to critically ill patients
transferred from district hospitals. Those patients
are usually transferred when they are in extremis
and have a very high mortality.
ECG display is erratic, as some of the old ECG
monitors tend to quit unexpectedly. Since pulse
oximetry was not available in every O.R., some
patients, mostly adults, went unmonitored. There
is no capnography capability in the O.R. despite
the presence of a capnograph, which is so old
it is no longer serviceable. Gas analysis is not
available. The Glostavents (anesthesia machines)
have fully functioning FiO2 monitors
when supplied with fresh 9 volt batteries. They
were never used until I started using them.
Drugs are in short supply. Fentanyl is infrequently
used since it costs much more than MSO4. Thus
head trauma cases are done with MSO4 and halothane.
Besides morphine, ketamine and pentazocine are
readily available. Succinylcholine and vecuronium
are the only available muscle relaxants. Local
anesthetics are very unpredictable, and some lots
or individual vials seem to produce no clinical
effect at all. The use of LMAs is rare despite
their availability in most sizes. I was told that
copious secretions in Africans make the LMA difficult
to use.
Obviously there is much more to volunteering than
what is described above. Each experience for each
volunteer is different; and the way they adapt to
teaching under very different conditions is challenging.
The goal of our teaching program is to help them
do a better job with what resources they have. Obviously,
knowledge is the best way to maximize one’s
resources, and teaching is the best resource we
can share. As our volunteer noted, “It’s
a wonderful experience, and I want to go back.”
Try it, you just might like it!
| |
|
Phillip
O. Bridenbaugh, M.D., is Professor Emeritus,
Department of Anesthesiology, University of
Cincinnati Medical Center, Cincinnati, Ohio.
He was ASA President in 1997. |
|
|